Pilgrim Colonial Appraisal Services provides independent residential as-is appraisals, as-repaired appraisals, and after repair value appraisals throughout Springfield, East Longmeadow, Longmeadow, Chicopee, Wilbraham, and surrounding Western Massachusetts communities. These assignments can help homeowners, investors, attorneys, buyers, and other intended users understand the difference between a property's current market value and its prospective value after specifically identified repairs or improvements.
As-Is Value vs. As-Repaired Value
An as-is and as-repaired appraisal may involve two different value opinions for the same property. The distinction depends on the property's condition and the assumptions established for the appraisal assignment.
The property's market value based on its current condition and characteristics as of the effective date of the appraisal.
A prospective opinion of value based on the assumption that clearly identified repairs, renovations, or improvements have been completed as described in the appraisal assignment.
What Is an ARV Appraisal?
ARV commonly refers to after repair value. An ARV appraisal estimates the market value a property may have after specified repairs or improvements are completed.
The appraiser does not simply add the estimated cost of renovations to the current value. The analysis considers how buyers in the relevant market react to renovated properties and how comparable sales support the prospective condition and utility of the subject.
An after repair value appraisal may be particularly useful when a property is dated, damaged, partially renovated, purchased for rehabilitation, or being evaluated before substantial improvements are made.
Repair Cost Does Not Automatically Equal Added Market Value
A $50,000 renovation does not necessarily increase a property's market value by $50,000. Market reaction depends on the type and quality of the improvements, the property's location, buyer expectations, overall price range, competing inventory, and the extent to which the improvements are typical for the market.
When Is an As-Is or As-Repaired Appraisal Useful?
Real Estate Investors
Investors evaluating a potential rehabilitation project may need both the current as-is value and an estimated after repair value before making an acquisition or renovation decision.
Renovation Planning
Homeowners considering substantial renovations may want to understand how a proposed improvement program could affect the property's market position once completed.
Distressed or Dated Properties
Properties requiring repairs, modernization, deferred maintenance, or significant updating may require separate analysis of current condition and prospective repaired condition.
Private Purchase Decisions
Buyers considering a property that requires substantial work may seek an independent appraisal before committing to the acquisition and improvement plan.
Estate or Legal Matters
Attorneys, estates, heirs, or other parties may occasionally require analysis of a property's current condition and a hypothetical repaired condition depending on the intended use of the assignment.
Private Financing Decisions
An independent valuation may be useful when private parties need to understand current or prospective residential value outside of a traditional lender-ordered appraisal.
How an As-Repaired Appraisal Works
- Define the proposed repairs or improvements. The appraisal must clearly identify what work is assumed to be completed. Plans, specifications, contractor estimates, renovation descriptions, or other documentation may be useful depending on the assignment.
- Inspect and analyze the property. The appraiser considers the property's current condition, quality, layout, site, improvements, deferred maintenance, and other relevant characteristics.
- Research the competitive market. Comparable sales are analyzed with particular attention to properties that reflect the subject's expected condition and utility after the proposed work is completed.
- Develop the as-is value when required. The current condition of the property is analyzed using market evidence that reflects how buyers react to properties with similar condition and utility.
- Develop the prospective as-repaired value. The appraiser analyzes the property subject to the identified repairs or improvements being completed and reconciles the available market evidence into an opinion of prospective value.
What Information Is Needed for an As-Repaired Appraisal?
The reliability of an as-repaired valuation depends in part on how clearly the proposed improvements are defined. Depending on the property and scope of the assignment, useful information may include:
- Renovation plans or specifications
- Contractor estimates or scope-of-work documents
- Descriptions of proposed kitchen and bathroom improvements
- Planned flooring, roofing, siding, windows, or mechanical updates
- Proposed additions or changes in living area
- Basement finishing or other changes in utility
- Quality and level of finishes anticipated after renovation
Important: An as-repaired appraisal is based on the specific improvements identified in the assignment. Significant changes to the proposed renovation plan may change the market value conclusion and may require additional appraisal analysis.
How Appraisers Estimate After Repair Value
After repair value is generally supported by market evidence from properties that reflect the anticipated condition, quality, utility, and market appeal of the subject after the proposed improvements are completed.
The most relevant comparable sales are not necessarily the properties with the most expensive renovations. The analysis should focus on properties that compete with the subject in the eyes of typical buyers within the same market segment.
Differences in living area, site, location, quality, condition, room count, basement utility, garages, amenities, and other market-recognized features are also considered when developing the value conclusion.
As-Repaired Value Is Not a Renovation Guarantee
An as-repaired appraisal provides an opinion of market value based on the hypothetical or prospective condition described in the assignment. It does not guarantee that renovation costs will remain within budget, that a project will be completed on schedule, or that a property will ultimately sell for a particular amount.
Market conditions may also change between the appraisal effective date and the completion of a renovation project.
Frequently Asked Questions About As-Is & As-Repaired Appraisals
What is an as-is appraisal?
An as-is appraisal develops an opinion of market value based on the property's actual condition and characteristics as of the effective date of the appraisal.
What is an as-repaired appraisal?
An as-repaired appraisal develops an opinion of value based on the assumption that specifically identified repairs or improvements have been completed. The appraisal should clearly describe the condition being assumed.
What does ARV mean in real estate?
ARV generally means after repair value. It refers to the estimated market value of a property after specified renovation or rehabilitation work has been completed.
How is after repair value calculated?
After repair value is developed from market evidence rather than simply adding renovation costs to the property's current value. The appraiser analyzes comparable properties that reflect the subject's anticipated condition and utility after completion of the proposed work.
Can an appraiser provide both as-is and as-repaired values?
Yes, when appropriate for the assignment. A report may include separate value opinions reflecting the property's current condition and a defined prospective repaired condition.
Do I need contractor estimates for an ARV appraisal?
Not every assignment requires the same documentation, but the proposed repairs should be clearly defined. Contractor estimates, plans, specifications, or detailed renovation descriptions may help establish the condition being assumed in the appraisal.
Can an investor order an ARV appraisal?
Yes. A real estate investor may order a private appraisal when an independent opinion of current or prospective residential market value is needed for an acquisition or renovation decision.
How much does an as-repaired appraisal cost?
Fees depend on the property type, complexity, scope of work, proposed improvements, market data, and whether multiple value opinions are required. You can review our general guide to home appraisal costs in Massachusetts for additional information.
As-Is & As-Repaired Appraiser Serving Western Massachusetts
Pilgrim Colonial Appraisal Services provides residential as-is, as-repaired, and after repair value appraisal services throughout Springfield, East Longmeadow, Longmeadow, Chicopee, Wilbraham, West Springfield, Agawam, Westfield, Ludlow, Holyoke, and other selected Western Massachusetts communities.
Renovation value can vary substantially by neighborhood, price range, property type, quality, and buyer expectations. For that reason, each ARV appraisal is developed within the context of the subject property's actual competitive market.
View our complete Western Massachusetts appraisal service area .
Related Residential Appraisal Services
Pilgrim Colonial also provides private residential market value appraisals , pre-listing appraisals , estate and date-of-death valuations , and divorce appraisal services .
Need an As-Is or As-Repaired Appraisal?
If you need an independent opinion of a property's current value, prospective after repair value, or both, Pilgrim Colonial Appraisal Services can provide residential appraisal services throughout our Western Massachusetts service area.
Request an As-Is / As-Repaired Appraisal